Bankruptcy Opinions from the Eastern District of Michigan United States Bankruptcy Court

Detroit Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 Consumer Bankruptcy Filings

 I, Walter Metzen, will provide, free of charge as part of your free initial Bankruptcy Analysis, a means test calculation to determine if you are eligible for Chapter 7 Bankruptcy.  Nearly 90% of the people who walk through my door are eligible to file a Chapter 7 Bankruptcy in Michigan and get a permanent discharge of their debt. With Chapter 13 Bankruptcy in Michigan, we can develop and affordable repayment plan to fit every budget.
 

 Contact me, Michigan bankruptcy attorney Walter Metzen to learn more about how I can help you get a Fresh Financial Start!.

In re: SHAUN M. RUCKES, Debtor.

06-58969-Ws Chapter 13 Debtor. If nothing else, this case points out the potential pitfalls of pro se filings and reliance on non-professional advice. Signed on March 07, 2007 s Walter Shapero Walter Shapero United States Bankruptcy Judge

 

UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT
EASTERN DISTRICT OF MICHIGAN
SOUTHERN DIVISION
In re:
SHAUN M. RUCKES, Case No. 06-58969-WS
Chapter 13
Debtor. Hon. Walter Shapero

___________________________________/
OPINION DENYING MOTION FOR REINSTATEMENT OF CASE
Debtor, acting pro se, filed this chapter 13 case on December 20, 2006. Included among the then filed papers was an Exhibit D being the Debtor’sStatement of Compliance with Credit Counseling Requirement which was signed by Debtor and dated November 21, 2006, and stated that Debtor had received the required pre-filing credit counseling briefing. The required certificate issued and signed by the credit counseling service provider was NOT, however, attached as the form instructed it to be. The Debtor thereafter sought and obtained an order permitting the case filing fee to be paid in installments, the first one of which was due on January 16, 2007. There is a docket notation stating that the required pre-filing credit counseling certificate (signed by the service provider) was to be filed by January 4, 2007. It was not filed by that date. Accordingly on January 9, 2007, an order was entered dismissing the case for failure to have filed that particular certificate and notice of its entry was sent to Debtor. On January 29, 2007, Debtor filed a document asking for reinstatement of the case saying, “we have made the first installment for the filing on January 17, 2007, as indicated on record.” Apparently the Debtor did not read or understand the Order Dismissing the Case and thought the case had been dismissed because the first filing fee installment  was not paid or paid timely. That reinstatement request was set for a hearing on February 27, 2007. On February 20, 2007, the Debtor filed a Certificate of Debtor Education which in fact was the pre- discharge personal financial management course certificate required by code section 727(a)(11). It was NOT the prefiling credit counseling briefing certificate signed by the service provider required  by code section 109(h), the failure to file which occasioned the Dismissal Order. That filed certificate  states that the personal financial management course involved was taken on January 10, 2007. At the reinstatement motion hearing, the Court at least did not then fully appreciate that the certificate  filed by the Debtor on February 20, 2007, was NOT the missing 109(h) prefiling credit counseling  certificate and dealt with the motion assuming that it was. On that assumption, the issue discussed  at the hearing was whether or not the Debtor’s stated ignorance of the prefiling requirement (in light  of a consultation with apparently a non-lawyer friend about the requirement) met the statutory  standard of “exigent circumstances that merit the waiver” of that prefiling requirement. However,  more careful post hearing review of the file indicated, as noted, that the filed certificate was NOT in  fact the required one. So, what we have here is that (1) at the time the case was filed while the  Debtor signed and filed a statement saying that the Debtor had received the required pre-filing credit  counseling briefing, Debtor has yet to produce a certificate to that effect signed by the briefing  provider; (2) the certificate actually filed by the Debtor was a different one, which is to be filed post  petition and predischarge, which certified Debtor received the instructional course concerning  personal financial management; and, (3) the Debtor, perhaps not fully appreciating the certificate filed  was the wrong one, argued that ignorance of the prefiling credit counseling requirement was the  reason it did not occur and believed the requirement had by then been fulfilled which should thereby  permit reinstatement of the case.  Post filing, Debtor apparently came to recognize the need to have fulfilled the, or a,  requirement but then took the wrong course or briefing. Why Debtor took the indicated particular  3  financial management course at the indicated time or why or under what circumstances or by whose  advice or direction Debtor did so is not clear from the record and it need not be at this point. What  is clear is that while the Debtor did aver in a pleading the correct pre-filing briefing was received,  Debtor has failed to produce the required certificate to that effect from the provider and has had  ample opportunity to do so, and, given Debtor’s argument and position, it is likely it did not in fact  occur at all. If nothing else, this case points out the potential pitfalls of pro se filings and reliance on  non-professional advice.  It should be noted that all of the initially filed (on December 20, 2006) bankruptcy documents,  including the indicated Exhibit D certificate signed by Debtor, were dated either November 20 or 21,  2006, and thus presumably prepared some 30 days before the case was actually filed. The Exhibit  D certificate and form signed and filed by the Debtor specifically says, “Attach a copy of the  certificate,” (referring obviously to the one to be signed by the agency supplying the required  briefing). That same document talks about a prefiling “credit counseling” requirement both in its title  and at least in three or more other places, in language a lay person can understand, and does so  “under penalty of perjury,” - all of which should direct and call a debtor’s attention to what that  document is saying and referring to or at least heighten the need for further inquiry. Thus in sum,  while Debtor may have been in fact actually cognitively ignorant of the prefiling briefing requirement,  that ignorance arose from the fact that Debtor failed to read and understand the clear language in the  very document Debtor signed and what it said. Its very language put any reasonably literate person,  even a lay person, on notice of the prefiling briefing requirement, and in this case, in plenty of time  for the Debtor to have fulfilled that requirement or to at least ask questions about it of a  knowledgeable person. While our Court should and properly does accommodate filings by debtors  4  without counsel, that does not thereby mean that it can or should extend or stretch that  accommodation to the breaking point to even a well meaning, good faith debtor under the recited  facts. Even if the Court were willing to accept Debtor’s argued ignorance, and even if what Debtor  took and filed was the correct briefing, absent materially more, such would not in any event constitute  the “exigent circumstances meriting the waiver” of the prepetition filing requirement the statute  requires. The word “exigent,” by definition essentially contemplates the existence of a situation of emergency or immediacy which offers few if any options. That is simply not the case here. To decide  otherwise would be to essentially read the prefiling requirements totally out of the statute in almost  every such pro se case. Regardless of what a Court might think of the statutory requirement itself,  it is not free to go that far.


Accordingly, the motion for reinstatement is DENIED.
.
Signed on March 07, 2007
/s/ Walter Shapero
Walter Shapero
United States Bankruptcy Judge

Contact me, Detroit bankruptcy lawyer Walter Metzen today to schedule your free initial consultation. I also offer clients flexible appointment times and same day appointments if necessary. Get in touch with me today to learn how filing bankruptcy may be beneficial for you and your family. Why should you hire a Board Certified Bankruptcy Specialist? Click Here. My office has handled over 10,000 bankruptcy cases in Michigan and will apply this experience to your case as well. My office prides itself on fast, detailed, personal service. There are many different aspects to a bankruptcy case. Some of the different aspects are listed on the links below for you to explore. If you have any questions while exploring this site or would like a free personal bankruptcy consultation, contact my office at (313) 962-4656 or toll free 888-777-FILE.

 Contact me, bankruptcy attorney Walter Metzen to learn more about how I can help you get a Fresh Financial Start!.

 Be sure to Obtain a copy of your Credit Report after your Michigan Bankruptcy Filing and check it for Mistakes.

Contact me, bankruptcy attorney Walter Metzen to learn more about how the new Chapter 7 bankruptcy law may affect your case. I offer a free initial consultation so we can discuss your case personally.

We are a Debt Relief Agency helping people file for bankruptcy relief under the Bankruptcy Code. Let us help you decide if bankruptcy is right for you.

Bankruptcy attorney Walter Metzen represents clients throughout Southeast Michigan, including the communities of Detroit, Southfield, Warren, Roseville, Farmington Hills, Ann Arbor, Belleville, Canton, Clinton Township, Dearborn, Dearborn Heights, Hamtramck, Highland Park, Holland, Howell, Lincoln Park, Livonia, Macomb, Northville, Plymouth, Port Huron, Redford, Rochester, Saginaw, Southfield, Sterling Heights, Taylor, Trenton, Troy, Westland, Wyandotte, Ypsilanti, Mount Clemens, Howell, Oakland County, Macomb County, Wayne County, Washtenaw County, Livingston County, and all of the surrounding areas.

 


 

Detroit Bankruptcy Lawyer Detroit Bankruptcy Lawyers Walter Metzen Detroit Bankruptcy Lawyer Detroit Bankruptcy Attorney Detroit Bankruptcy Attorneys Filing Bankruptcy in Michigan Lawyer Filing Bankruptcy in Michigan Declare Bankruptcy Detroit Fresh Start Bankruptcy Detroit Southfield Michigan Bankruptcy lawyers Declaring Bankruptcy in Michigan Michigan Credit Counseling Lawyer Board Certified Bankruptcy Lawyers Warren Bankruptcy Lawyer Walter Metzen Bankruptcy Lawyer Attorney for Bankruptcy in Wayne County Bankruptcy Lawyer Oakland County Detroit Chapter 7 Lawyer  Southfield Michigan Bankruptcy Lawyer Michigan Bankruptcy Specialist Macomb County Bankruptcy Lawyer Fresh Start Bankruptcy Lawyers of Michigan Birmingham Michigan Bankruptcy Lawyers Michigan Bankruptcy Helpline Oakland County Michigan Bankruptcy Specialists Michigan Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Lawyers Michigan Fresh Start Bankruptcy Law Office Wayne County Debt Relief Agency Michigan Credit and Debt Counseling Lawyers Detroit Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Board Certified Specialist Walter Metzen Detroit Bankruptcy Attorneys Helping People File Bankruptcy Detroit Credit Counseling and Bankruptcy Services Consumer Bankruptcy Attorney in Michigan Detroit Michigan Bankruptcy Attorney Detroit Michigan Bankruptcy Lawyer Filing a Personal Bankruptcy How to declare personal bankruptcy in michigan How to File Bankruptcy in Detroit Declaring Bankruptcy in Macomb County Michigan Detroit Bankruptcy Court Directory Best Bankruptcy Lawyer in Detroit Michigan Attorney Walter Metzen Online Help Filing Bankruptcy In Detroit Michigan Michigan Chapter 13 Bankruptcy Lawyers Board Certified Specialist Detroit Chapter 13 Bankruptcy Lawyers Stop Foreclosure Repayment Plan Chapter 7 Lawyers In Detroit Wayne County Michigan Detroit Credit Counseling Information Detroit Credit Counseling Debt Settlement and Bankruptcy Lawyers serving Metro Detroit Metroit Detroit Bankruptcy Lawyers Consumer Bankruptcy Specialist Walter Metzen Board Certified by the American Bankruptcy Institute Detroit Debt Relief Agency Helping People File Bankruptcy in Michigan The Law Office of Walter Metzen Michigan Bankruptcy Lawyers Fresh Start Bankruptcy Law Office Metro Detroit Michigan Bankruptcy Law Firm Serving all of Metropolitan Detroit Walter Metzen Consumer Bankruptcy Specialist Certified by the American Bankruptcy Institute Wayne County Bankruptcy Attorneys Southfield Bankruptcy Attorneys Consumer Bankruptcy Specialists Oakland County Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 Bankruptcy Lawyer Certified Specialist File Personal Bankruptcy in Michigan Filing Chapter 13 Bankruptcy in Michigan Declaring Chapter 7 Bankruptcy in Michigan Legal Help Filing Bankruptcy in Michigan Stopping Foreclosure in Michigan Help Filing Michigan Bankruptcy Walter Metzen Bankruptcy Lawyer Michigan Bankruptcy Michigan Bankruptcy Lawyers Michigan Bankruptcy Attorneys Helping Consumers get a FRESH START Macomb County Credit Card Lawyers Bankruptcy and Debt Settlement Michigan Bankruptcy Credit Counseling and Debt Negotiation Attorneys Royal Oak Bankruptcy Lawyers Wyandotte Michigan Bankruptcy Lawyers Fresh Start Bankruptcy Lawyers of Michigan. How to Declare Bankruptcy in Michigan Michigan Bankruptcy and Credit Counseling Lawyers Michigan Credit Card Relief Lawyers Fresh Start Bankruptcy Lawyers of Detroit Michigan Credit and Debt Counseling Bankruptcy Lawyers of Michigan Lawyers Detroit Bankruptcy Bankruptcy Lawyers of Michigan Walter Metzen Board Certified Consumer Bankruptcy Specialist 888-4WALTER Michigan Bankruptcy Centers Michigan Bankruptcy Counselors Michigan Bankruptcy Court Directory Fresh Start Michigan Bankruptcy Law Offices Michigan Bankruptcy Law Center Michigan Bankruptcy Laws Filing Bankruptcy in Michigan Michigan Bankruptcy Attorney Walter Metzen Specialist in Consumer Bankruptcy Laws Board Certified by the American Bankruptcy Institute Michigan Bankruptcy Online Michigan Bankruptcy Services. Michigan Chapter 13 Bankruptcy Attorneys Metro Detroit Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Lawyer Michigan Credit Counseling Credit Counselors of Michigan Michigan Debt Assistance Michigan Debt Relief Agency Fresh Start Bankruptcy Law Center Motor City Bankruptcy Laws Stop Wage Garnishment in Michigan Detroit Bankruptcy Lawyer Walter Metzen Consumer Bankruptcy Attorney Walter Metzen Michigan Fresh Start Lawyers Downriver Bankruptcy Lawyer Michigan Fresh Start Bankruptcy Offices of Detroit Bankruptcy Attorneys Detroit Filing Personal Bankruptcy in Michigan Filing Personal Bankruptcy in Michigan Fresh Start Bankruptcy Lawyers Fresh Start Bankruptcy Law Office of Detroit

 

 Content Footer