Michigan Bankruptcy Laws/Chapter 13 Bankruptcy

Detroit Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 Consumer Bankruptcy Filings

 I, Walter Metzen, will provide, free of charge as part of your free initial Bankruptcy Analysis, a means test calculation to determine if you are eligible for Chapter 7 Bankruptcy.  Nearly 90% of the people who walk through my door are eligible to file a Chapter 7 Bankruptcy in Michigan and get a permanent discharge of their debt. With Chapter 13 Bankruptcy in Michigan, we can develop and affordable repayment plan to fit every budget.

 Contact me, Michigan bankruptcy attorney Walter Metzen to learn more about how I can help you get a Fresh Financial Start!.


A Small New Window on Chapter 13

Contributing Editors: Gordon Bermant
Burke, Virginia
Ed Flynn
Executive Office for U.S. Trustees(1)

      Last March in this column we called for new studies of chapter 13 cases that would provide factual information vitally relevant to the policy debates surrounding proposed consumer bankruptcy reforms.(2) Some relevant information has since been published by Professor Scott Norberg of Mississippi College School of Law.(3) Norberg's analytic framework and approach to the data are salutary. His conclusions are strong and immediately relevant to current consumer bankruptcy issues - but his data are too few to support the conclusions as other than tentative. The conclusions must be tested across a wide range of bankruptcy districts. Here we briefly review Norberg's work and re-emphasize the importance of collecting and cumulating such data at a national level.

The Analytic Framework

      Norberg framed his study to respond directly to the question of chapter choice: what are the consequences for debtor and their creditors arising from choices between chapter 13 and chapter 7? The analysis emphasizes the distinct interests of secured vs. unsecured creditors: under the present Code secured creditors appear to be better off with a chapter 7 filing while unsecured creditors should benefit more from [a successful] chapter 13 plan. Which chapter works better for a particular debtor depends on the distribution of the debt: debtors with relatively high secured or priority debts fare better in chapter 13, all else equal, while debtors with little or no secured debt should be better off in chapter 7.

      There is thus a three-way tension built into the chapter choice decision that is now determined almost entirely by the debtor:(4) a tension between the debtor and each of the two major creditor classes, and a tension between secured and unsecured creditors themselves. In the current debates about changing the rules for chapter choice through means-testing, the tension between secured and unsecured creditors has not been nearly so visible publicly as that between the unsecured creditors and debtor community representatives. As Norberg observes, some recent statutory proposals and the Supreme Court's ruling in Associates Commercial v. Rash(5) provide new protections to secured creditors in chapter 13.(6)

      We do not have a clear public national view of how debtors progress through chapter 13 and how well their creditors do in terms of eventual payout.(7) One approach to gaining that view is to go district by district to gain the relevant longitudinal perspective. Norberg provided that perspective for the Southern District of Mississippi, circa 1998.

The Data

      The data comprised 71 chapter 13 cases filed in Mississippi Southern between 1992 and 1998; all were closed between January and June of 1998.(8) By beginning with the standing trustee's closing report and working back to the schedules and plan, Norberg could show the progress, or lack of it, of these filings to a successful completion and discharge. Comparing schedules to plans(9) was also a critical part of the analysis. Only with that comparison can we understand how chapter 13 operated in fact to regulate the extent of creditor disbursements and to aid or thwart the debtor's progress through to a chapter 13 discharge.

      In a series of 26 tables Norberg wrings the useful information out of the data from the 71 cases. We will not summarize the findings here except as they bear on the significant conclusions described in the next section.

The Conclusions

      Consistent with earlier reports from other districts, approximately one-third of the Mississippi Southern debtors (23 out of 71)completed their chapter 13 plans and received discharges.(10) Of the two-thirds whose cases were dismissed from chapter 13 before completion, more than 70% (35 out of 48) were dismissed after plan confirmation. This suggests that initial appearances of feasibility do not accurately predict successful completion.

      In particular, debtor income was not a predictor of chapter 13 success in Mississippi Southern.(11) Norberg argues, with minor qualification, that these findings "undercut" the case for means-testing to limit participation in chapter 7.(12) Why should we expect that debtors whose bankruptcy choice is limited to chapter 13 will be more likely to succeed than these debtors, who entered the chapter voluntarily? But he further notes that the policy intent of means testing may be to exclude relative high-income people from chapter 7 without concern for the probability of their success in chapter 13.(13)

      Unexpectedly, there was no statistically significant relationship between the percentage payback proposed and the probability of completing a plan. Nor was there a significant relationship between the proposed durations of the plans and the likelihood of successful completion.(14) On the other hand, the data did allow the conclusion that debtors who had filed one earlier chapter 13 case were more likely than other debtors to complete the plan successfully.

Overall, the most compelling findings in the data were these:

  • debtors who successfully completed their plans had significantly higher secured debt at the time of filing than did debtors whose cases were eventually dismissed. The higher debt likely relates to more assets. In a nutshell then, debtors for whom chapter 13 provides the best chance to keep their major possessions are more likely to make the plan work for them. From a debtor's perspective, this seems to be what chapter 13 is about.(15)

  • The distributions proposed for unsecured creditors in the 71 cases ranged from 0% to 100%. While almost one-third of the debtors proposed 100% repayment, almost one-half proposed to repay no more than 15%.(16) Only about one-third of all the scheduled debt was unsecured (including priority and general).(17) Norberg concludes that "debtors pay precious little unsecured debt in chapter 13."(18)


The Weaknesses

      Norberg's analysis of the current Code and case law, and the implications of legislative proposals, are commendable. Also to be commended is the effort to illustrate how chapter 13 works in fact. The weaknesses arise from the small sample size and the probability that Mississippi Southern is a statistically aberrant district. To begin with, the percentage of chapter 13 filings (41%) is considerably higher than the national average. Second, the income distribution within the district is lower than average; the median income for the study population, $14,400, would count as poverty level for families in many parts of the country. (One wonders what the median income of chapter 7 filers is in the district.) Third, the median duration of proposed plans, 48 months, may be longer than average. And so on. Without data from many other districts, the validity of the conclusions based on these 71 cases cannot be gauged beyond their borders.


The Future

      We are optimistic that it will be possible to pursue this kind of analysis into other districts. There are administrative reasons to do so that are important irrespective of how the results work out for the more general debates about consumer bankruptcy policy. The support that the Mississippi Southern data provide for some earlier published conclusions, as well as the doubt they cast on others, show the value of developing an accurate portrayal of the substance and trajectories of chapter 13 cases throughout the country -- a portrayal that permits a national summary without losing the importance of regional and local variations.


End Notes:

1. All views expressed in this article are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the views of the Executive Office for U.S. Trustees.

2. Bermant, Gordon, One Hand Clapping: What We Know, and Still Need to Know, About Consumer Cases. Amer. Bnkry. Inst. J., 1999 (March), 16-17.

3. Norberg, Scott F., Consumer Bankruptcy's New Clothes: An Empirical Study of Discharge and Debt Collection in Chapter 13. 7 Amer. Bnkry. Inst. L. Rev.415 (1999).

4. Of course we recognize that the debtor's counsel and the local legal culture have a significant influence on a debtor's chapter choice. See Braucher, Jean, Lawyers and Consumer Bankruptcy: One Code, Many Cultures, 67 Am. Bakr. L.J. (Fall 1993)

5. 520 U.S. 953 (1997)

6. Norberg, supra n.3, at 426.

7. The Executive Office for U.S. Trustees maintains careful records of amounts disbursed annually to different creditor classes in chapter 13. Over the past several years, payments to secureds have been 2.5 to 3 times greater than payments to general unsecureds. The policy significance of this ratio, and the dollar amounts behind them, are difficult to discern without additional information about the details of the plans within which the disbursements were made: their duration, percentages of debt totals owed at the time of filing, extent of secured debt cram down, amounts payed outside of the plans, and so on. See Norberg, supra n.3, at 434. There are two numerical errors in the table as published: the "other" payments have not been included in the total for 1998, and the total reported for 1994 should be corrected to read $1,844,750,141.

8. Every 19th cased closed was selected. This was a 5.2% sample of the 1,371 chapter 13 cases closed in the district during the period. Norberg, supra n. 3, at 427.

9. Norberg does not report on the prevalence of amended schedules and how the research accounted for them. We are told by knowledgeable people that amendments are frequent in the early stages of chapter 13, and that relying on the first filed schedules will produce a misleading picture of the debtor's financial affairs.

10. Norberg, supra n.3, at 440.

11. Id., at 442.

12. Id., at 441.

13. Id.,at 442.

14. Id., at 447, table 15.

15. Id., at 448-449.

16. Id., at 445, table 13.

17. Id., at 454.

18. Id., at 461.

  Bankruptcy Basics - For Cases Filed on or after October 17, 2005 (pdf)
Bankruptcy Basics - For Cases Filed before October 17, 2005 (pdf)

Contact me, Detroit bankruptcy lawyer Walter Metzen today to schedule your free initial consultation. I also offer clients flexible appointment times and same day appointments if necessary. Get in touch with me today to learn how filing bankruptcy may be beneficial for you and your family. Why should you hire a Board Certified Bankruptcy Specialist? Click Here. My office has handled over 10,000 bankruptcy cases in Michigan and will apply this experience to your case as well. My office prides itself on fast, detailed, personal service. There are many different aspects to a bankruptcy case. Some of the different aspects are listed on the links below for you to explore. If you have any questions while exploring this site or would like a free personal bankruptcy consultation, contact my office at (313) 962-4656 or toll free 888-777-FILE.

 Contact me, bankruptcy attorney Walter Metzen to learn more about how I can help you get a Fresh Financial Start!.

 Be sure to Obtain a copy of your Credit Report after your Michigan Bankruptcy Filing and check it for Mistakes.

Contact me, bankruptcy attorney Walter Metzen to learn more about how the new Chapter 7 bankruptcy law may affect your case. I offer a free initial consultation so we can discuss your case personally.

We are a Debt Relief Agency helping people file for bankruptcy relief under the Bankruptcy Code. Let us help you decide if bankruptcy is right for you.

Bankruptcy attorney Walter Metzen represents clients throughout Southeast Michigan, including the communities of Detroit, Southfield, Warren, Roseville, Farmington Hills, Ann Arbor, Belleville, Canton, Clinton Township, Dearborn, Dearborn Heights, Hamtramck, Highland Park, Holland, Howell, Lincoln Park, Livonia, Macomb, Northville, Plymouth, Port Huron, Redford, Rochester, Saginaw, Southfield, Sterling Heights, Taylor, Trenton, Troy, Westland, Wyandotte, Ypsilanti, Mount Clemens, Howell, Oakland County, Macomb County, Wayne County, Washtenaw County, Livingston County, and all of the surrounding areas.



Detroit Bankruptcy Lawyer Detroit Bankruptcy Lawyers Walter Metzen Detroit Bankruptcy Lawyer Detroit Bankruptcy Attorney Detroit Bankruptcy Attorneys Filing Bankruptcy in Michigan Lawyer Filing Bankruptcy in Michigan Declare Bankruptcy Detroit Fresh Start Bankruptcy Detroit Southfield Michigan Bankruptcy lawyers Declaring Bankruptcy in Michigan Michigan Credit Counseling Lawyer Board Certified Bankruptcy Lawyers Warren Bankruptcy Lawyer Walter Metzen Bankruptcy Lawyer Attorney for Bankruptcy in Wayne County Bankruptcy Lawyer Oakland County Detroit Chapter 7 Lawyer  Southfield Michigan Bankruptcy Lawyer Michigan Bankruptcy Specialist Macomb County Bankruptcy Lawyer Fresh Start Bankruptcy Lawyers of Michigan Birmingham Michigan Bankruptcy Lawyers Michigan Bankruptcy Helpline Oakland County Michigan Bankruptcy Specialists Michigan Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Lawyers Michigan Fresh Start Bankruptcy Law Office Wayne County Debt Relief Agency Michigan Credit and Debt Counseling Lawyers Detroit Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Board Certified Specialist Walter Metzen Detroit Bankruptcy Attorneys Helping People File Bankruptcy Detroit Credit Counseling and Bankruptcy Services Consumer Bankruptcy Attorney in Michigan Detroit Michigan Bankruptcy Attorney Detroit Michigan Bankruptcy Lawyer Filing a Personal Bankruptcy How to declare personal bankruptcy in michigan How to File Bankruptcy in Detroit Declaring Bankruptcy in Macomb County Michigan Detroit Bankruptcy Court Directory Best Bankruptcy Lawyer in Detroit Michigan Attorney Walter Metzen Online Help Filing Bankruptcy In Detroit Michigan Michigan Chapter 13 Bankruptcy Lawyers Board Certified Specialist Detroit Chapter 13 Bankruptcy Lawyers Stop Foreclosure Repayment Plan Chapter 7 Lawyers In Detroit Wayne County Michigan Detroit Credit Counseling Information Detroit Credit Counseling Debt Settlement and Bankruptcy Lawyers serving Metro Detroit Metroit Detroit Bankruptcy Lawyers Consumer Bankruptcy Specialist Walter Metzen Board Certified by the American Bankruptcy Institute Detroit Debt Relief Agency Helping People File Bankruptcy in Michigan The Law Office of Walter Metzen Michigan Bankruptcy Lawyers Fresh Start Bankruptcy Law Office Metro Detroit Michigan Bankruptcy Law Firm Serving all of Metropolitan Detroit Walter Metzen Consumer Bankruptcy Specialist Certified by the American Bankruptcy Institute Wayne County Bankruptcy Attorneys Southfield Bankruptcy Attorneys Consumer Bankruptcy Specialists Oakland County Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 Bankruptcy Lawyer Certified Specialist File Personal Bankruptcy in Michigan Filing Chapter 13 Bankruptcy in Michigan Declaring Chapter 7 Bankruptcy in Michigan Legal Help Filing Bankruptcy in Michigan Stopping Foreclosure in Michigan Help Filing Michigan Bankruptcy Walter Metzen Bankruptcy Lawyer Michigan Bankruptcy Michigan Bankruptcy Lawyers Michigan Bankruptcy Attorneys Helping Consumers get a FRESH START Macomb County Credit Card Lawyers Bankruptcy and Debt Settlement Michigan Bankruptcy Credit Counseling and Debt Negotiation Attorneys Royal Oak Bankruptcy Lawyers Wyandotte Michigan Bankruptcy Lawyers Fresh Start Bankruptcy Lawyers of Michigan. How to Declare Bankruptcy in Michigan Michigan Bankruptcy and Credit Counseling Lawyers Michigan Credit Card Relief Lawyers Fresh Start Bankruptcy Lawyers of Detroit Michigan Credit and Debt Counseling Bankruptcy Lawyers of Michigan Lawyers Detroit Bankruptcy Bankruptcy Lawyers of Michigan Walter Metzen Board Certified Consumer Bankruptcy Specialist 888-4WALTER Michigan Bankruptcy Centers Michigan Bankruptcy Counselors Michigan Bankruptcy Court Directory Fresh Start Michigan Bankruptcy Law Offices Michigan Bankruptcy Law Center Michigan Bankruptcy Laws Filing Bankruptcy in Michigan Michigan Bankruptcy Attorney Walter Metzen Specialist in Consumer Bankruptcy Laws Board Certified by the American Bankruptcy Institute Michigan Bankruptcy Online Michigan Bankruptcy Services. Michigan Chapter 13 Bankruptcy Attorneys Metro Detroit Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Lawyer Michigan Credit Counseling Credit Counselors of Michigan Michigan Debt Assistance Michigan Debt Relief Agency Fresh Start Bankruptcy Law Center Motor City Bankruptcy Laws Stop Wage Garnishment in Michigan Detroit Bankruptcy Lawyer Walter Metzen Consumer Bankruptcy Attorney Walter Metzen Michigan Fresh Start Lawyers Downriver Bankruptcy Lawyer Michigan Fresh Start Bankruptcy Offices of Detroit Bankruptcy Attorneys Detroit Filing Personal Bankruptcy in Michigan Filing Personal Bankruptcy in Michigan Fresh Start Bankruptcy Lawyers Fresh Start Bankruptcy Law Office of Detroit


 Content Footer