Michigan Bankruptcy/Bankruptcy Causes

Detroit Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 Consumer Bankruptcy Filings

 I, Walter Metzen, will provide, free of charge as part of your free initial Bankruptcy Analysis, a means test calculation to determine if you are eligible for Chapter 7 Bankruptcy.  Nearly 90% of the people who walk through my door are eligible to file a Chapter 7 Bankruptcy in Michigan and get a permanent discharge of their debt. With Chapter 13 Bankruptcy in Michigan, we can develop and affordable repayment plan to fit every budget.

 

Click here to Download Bankruptcy Packet

Contact me, Michigan bankruptcy attorney Walter Metzen to learn more about how I can help you get a Fresh Financial Start!.

Exploring the (Complex) Causes of Consumer Bankruptcy

Contributing Editors:
Gordon Bermant
Burke, Va.

Ed Flynn
Executive Office for U.S. Trustees; Washington, D.C.
1

In an article published recently on the Internet, Prof. Robert Lawless presented data showing a tight and positive relationship between annual measurements of consumer debt level and the numbers of non-business bankruptcies filed in the same year.2 From the perspective of this column, which attempts to characterize bankruptcy questions by reference to quantitative information, Prof. Lawless's work provides a useful starting place to consider some problems facing the analysis of the causes of consumer bankruptcy. There are also lessons to be learned about the relationship between the causes of bankruptcy and decisions about how the bankruptcy system should operate.

It will come as no surprise that, as a general proposition, consumer bankruptcy filings fluctuate with debt levels. We would be surprised, in fact, if the opposite were true. But there is more to the story than that.

In the first place, different measures of consumer or household debt are published on a regular basis. Everything else being equal, we would expect that any of these measures would show the expected co-variation with filings. The truth is more complicated. For example, Prof. Lawless found that annual changes in household debt service burden measured over a 20-year period did not correlate closely with annual changes in non-business filings, even though other measures of debt did.3 Lawless concluded that the lack of a demonstrated relationship most likely arose from a combination of mis-estimations of household debt burden and insufficient sensitivity in the methods that he used to test the association between burden and bankruptcy filings.

The question of measurement sensitivity leads to the next point, which is that our intuition tells us that increases in debt level should be a cause of increased filings. That means that the debt levels should grow before their effects show up in the filings. We should expect the tightest relationships between the two factors to occur when debt levels reported for one year are compared to filing levels of the following year, or even the year after that. Using such offsets is often referred to as lagging one variable behind the other.

One study has shown that when bankruptcy filings were lagged one year behind debt service burden over the years 1981-99, a reasonably clear positive relationship emerged.4 The author of that study, Kim Kowalewski of the Congressional Budget Office, concluded that "[g]rowth in the filing rate tends to increase (or decrease) in the year following a greater (or smaller) increase in the debt-service burden. In particular, the slowdown in the rate's growth during the past few years [late 1990s] corresponds to smaller increases in the debt-service burden."5

We can get yet a closer view of relations between debt levels and filing levels by comparing percentage changes in both factors and lagging the bankruptcy numbers behind the debt-level numbers. The figure below demonstrates a tight relationship between changes in consumer debt levels (not debt service burdens) and filing levels lagged by two years. The relationship is shown over a 30-year period.6

 

Bankruptcies and Consumer Debt (years ended June 30, 1970-1999)

In sum, in spite of problems of data availability and methods for measuring the relationship between debt levels and filing levels, the conclusion that the two are causally related is supported by objective analysis as well as common sense. But that conclusion still cannot be the end of the story—for two reasons. First, we know that many consumers with large debts do not file for bankruptcy and that some consumers with low debts do file, so there must be more to the causes of filing, or not filing, than debt. Second, accepting that high consumer debt tends to produce bankruptcy provides an insufficient foundation for answering bankruptcy policy questions. We consider each of these reasons briefly.

The relatively tight connection between debt levels and bankruptcy rates only moves our search for answers one step back; for now, we must inquire about the causes of high debt levels. There are many candidates—e.g., marital break-up, job loss or illness. Increases in the availability of credit are another factor often cited. In addition, some have argued that a decline in moral standards (phrased as a reduction in shame or stigma associated with debt and bankruptcy) has produced both debt and bankruptcy growth.7

There are also candidates for causes of variations in bankruptcy filing rates that would not necessarily affect debt levels. These can arise with the law itself, including, for example, differences between states in their exemption levels and wage garnishment laws, as well as the provisions of the 1978 Act and subsequent amendments that have been called more or less "debtor-friendly." And of course, there are provisions of new legislation pending that are intended to affect both filing rates and choice of chapter by consumers. Taken all together, this list creates an almost impenetrable network of interconnected factors that are plausible causes of (or reasons for) a consumer's decision to file.

Efforts to discern the effect of divorce on bankruptcy filings is illustrative. One study concluded that divorce rates partially predicted consumer filing rates. The authors of the study interpreted the relationship using two different theories. One theory was that divorces cause bankruptcy because the dissolution of the household produces financial distress. The second theory was that divorce and bankruptcy are both examples of breaking promises, and that an increase in promise-breaking "across the board" has produced the increases in both divorces and bankruptcy filings. Although the authors of the study chose to emphasize the second theory over the first, they acknowledged that their data, standing alone, could not support their choice.8 This interpretive problem holds for all studies that attempt to assess the effect of changes in shame or stigma on bankruptcy filings, because there are no direct measures of such changes (or of the factors themselves); inevitably, their import resides in the judgment of the analyst. The judgments are not necessarily wrong, but they are always subject to a different interpretation that is not refutable by the numbers themselves.

This is why studies about the causes of bankruptcy provide ambiguous or insufficient guidance for answering bankruptcy policy questions. The data always require interpretations that include a set of assumptions that go beyond the numbers themselves. Given different assumptions, the numbers will be interpreted differently. If we assume that there is less shame in society than there used to be, we are likely to interpret statistics regarding debt, divorce and bankruptcy differently than if we assume otherwise, but the current data don't prove the assumption either way. Our attitudes about debtors and about appropriate legal changes are, nevertheless, guided by our assumptions as well as our interpretations of the data.


Footnotes

1 All views expressed in this article are those of the authors, and do not necessarily represent the views of the Executive Office for U.S. Trustees or the Department of Justice. 

2 Lawless, Robert M., "The Relationship Between Non-business Bankruptcy Filings and Various Basic Measures of Consumer Debt," (Version 1.1, July 18, 2001). 

3 This is a statistic reported by the Federal Reserve and is, approximately, the percentage of income absorbed by household debt service.  The failure to show a relationship between debt service burden and filings was over the 20-year period from 1980-00. Over the period from 1993-00, the expected positive relationship could be shown; this discrepancy is currently unexplained. The Federal Reserve states that the statistic is based on "rough approximations" gathered from several data sources. See www.federalreserve.gov/releases/housedebt/about.htm

4 Kowalewski, Kim, "Personal Bankruptcy: A Literature Review," Congressional Budget Office, September 2000, p. 10. This paper contains a very thoughtful analysis of the causes of consumer bankruptcy and how different views about them affect policy preferences. 

5 Id. at 9. 

6 See Flynn, Ed, and Bermant, Gordon, "On the Evidence of These Numbers: Why Consumers File for Bankruptcy," ABI Journal, April 2000, p. 22, for an earlier discussion of the significance of this graph. 

7 Buckley, F.H., and Brinig, Margaret F., "The Bankruptcy Puzzle," 27 J. Legal Stud. 187, 201-202, 205 (1998). See Kowalewski, supra n. 4, for a review of the different positions taken on this topic. 

8 Buckley and Brinig, supra n. 7



For a free consultation, please complete the Bankruptcy Startup Questionnaire..

Click here to Download Bankruptcy Packet



If you do not have access to a printer, contact the office at (313)962-4656 or 888-777-FILE and one will be mailed to your home.

The office is open 9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m. Monday through Friday. No appointment needed-simply walk-in, a Bankruptcy Attorney is always available.

The Bankruptcy Lawyers at the Bankruptcy Law Offices of Walter Metzen have been DEDICATED to helping Michigan residents file for bankruptcy under the United States Bankruptcy Laws for over 15 years with over 10,000 clients discharging millions of dollars of debt. We emphasize a complete financial makeover and offer our clients in office credit counseling and state of the art debtor education services to maximize the Fresh Start a Bankruptcy Discharge provides


Bankruptcy Basics - For Cases Filed on or after October 17, 2005 (pdf)
Bankruptcy Basics - For Cases Filed before October 17, 2005 (pdf)

  
Contact me, Detroit bankruptcy lawyer Walter Metzen today to schedule your free initial consultation. I also offer clients flexible appointment times and same day appointments if necessary. Get in touch with me today to learn how filing bankruptcy may be beneficial for you and your family. Why should you hire a Board Certified Bankruptcy Specialist? Click Here. My office has handled over 10,000 bankruptcy cases in Michigan and will apply this experience to your case as well. My office prides itself on fast, detailed, personal service. There are many different aspects to a bankruptcy case. Some of the different aspects are listed on the links below for you to explore. If you have any questions while exploring this site or would like a free personal bankruptcy consultation, contact my office at (313) 962-4656 or toll free 888-777-FILE. Let me help you Get a Fresh Financial Start today!

 Contact me, bankruptcy attorney Walter Metzen to learn more about how I can help you get a Fresh Financial Start!.

 Be sure to Obtain a copy of your Credit Report after your Michigan Bankruptcy Filing and check it for Mistakes.

Contact me, bankruptcy attorney Walter Metzen to learn more about how the new Chapter 7 bankruptcy law may affect your case. I offer a free initial consultation so we can discuss your case personally.

We are a Debt Relief Agency helping people file for bankruptcy relief under the Bankruptcy Code. Let us help you decide if bankruptcy is right for you.

Bankruptcy attorney Walter Metzen represents clients throughout Southeast Michigan, including the communities of Detroit, Southfield, Warren, Roseville, Farmington Hills, Ann Arbor, Belleville, Canton, Clinton Township, Dearborn, Dearborn Heights, Hamtramck, Highland Park, Holland, Howell, Lincoln Park, Livonia, Macomb, Northville, Plymouth, Port Huron, Redford, Rochester, Saginaw, Southfield, Sterling Heights, Taylor, Trenton, Troy, Westland, Wyandotte, Ypsilanti, Mount Clemens, Howell, Oakland County, Macomb County, Wayne County, Washtenaw County, Livingston County, and all of the surrounding areas.

 


 

Detroit Bankruptcy Lawyer Detroit Bankruptcy Lawyers Walter Metzen Detroit Bankruptcy Lawyer Detroit Bankruptcy Attorney Detroit Bankruptcy Attorneys Filing Bankruptcy in Michigan Lawyer Filing Bankruptcy in Michigan Declare Bankruptcy Detroit Fresh Start Bankruptcy Detroit Southfield Michigan Bankruptcy lawyers Declaring Bankruptcy in Michigan Michigan Credit Counseling Lawyer Board Certified Bankruptcy Lawyers Warren Bankruptcy Lawyer Walter Metzen Bankruptcy Lawyer Attorney for Bankruptcy in Wayne County Bankruptcy Lawyer Oakland County Detroit Chapter 7 Lawyer  Southfield Michigan Bankruptcy Lawyer Michigan Bankruptcy Specialist Macomb County Bankruptcy Lawyer Fresh Start Bankruptcy Lawyers of Michigan Birmingham Michigan Bankruptcy Lawyers Michigan Bankruptcy Helpline Oakland County Michigan Bankruptcy Specialists Michigan Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Lawyers Michigan Fresh Start Bankruptcy Law Office Wayne County Debt Relief Agency Michigan Credit and Debt Counseling Lawyers Detroit Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Board Certified Specialist Walter Metzen Detroit Bankruptcy Attorneys Helping People File Bankruptcy Detroit Credit Counseling and Bankruptcy Services Consumer Bankruptcy Attorney in Michigan Detroit Michigan Bankruptcy Attorney Detroit Michigan Bankruptcy Lawyer Filing a Personal Bankruptcy How to declare personal bankruptcy in michigan How to File Bankruptcy in Detroit Declaring Bankruptcy in Macomb County Michigan Detroit Bankruptcy Court Directory Best Bankruptcy Lawyer in Detroit Michigan Attorney Walter Metzen Online Help Filing Bankruptcy In Detroit Michigan Michigan Chapter 13 Bankruptcy Lawyers Board Certified Specialist Detroit Chapter 13 Bankruptcy Lawyers Stop Foreclosure Repayment Plan Chapter 7 Lawyers In Detroit Wayne County Michigan Detroit Credit Counseling Information Detroit Credit Counseling Debt Settlement and Bankruptcy Lawyers serving Metro Detroit Metroit Detroit Bankruptcy Lawyers Consumer Bankruptcy Specialist Walter Metzen Board Certified by the American Bankruptcy Institute Detroit Debt Relief Agency Helping People File Bankruptcy in Michigan The Law Office of Walter Metzen Michigan Bankruptcy Lawyers Fresh Start Bankruptcy Law Office Metro Detroit Michigan Bankruptcy Law Firm Serving all of Metropolitan Detroit Walter Metzen Consumer Bankruptcy Specialist Certified by the American Bankruptcy Institute Wayne County Bankruptcy Attorneys Southfield Bankruptcy Attorneys Consumer Bankruptcy Specialists Oakland County Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 Bankruptcy Lawyer Certified Specialist File Personal Bankruptcy in Michigan Filing Chapter 13 Bankruptcy in Michigan Declaring Chapter 7 Bankruptcy in Michigan Legal Help Filing Bankruptcy in Michigan Stopping Foreclosure in Michigan Help Filing Michigan Bankruptcy Walter Metzen Bankruptcy Lawyer Michigan Bankruptcy Michigan Bankruptcy Lawyers Michigan Bankruptcy Attorneys Helping Consumers get a FRESH START Macomb County Credit Card Lawyers Bankruptcy and Debt Settlement Michigan Bankruptcy Credit Counseling and Debt Negotiation Attorneys Royal Oak Bankruptcy Lawyers Wyandotte Michigan Bankruptcy Lawyers Fresh Start Bankruptcy Lawyers of Michigan. How to Declare Bankruptcy in Michigan Michigan Bankruptcy and Credit Counseling Lawyers Michigan Credit Card Relief Lawyers Fresh Start Bankruptcy Lawyers of Detroit Michigan Credit and Debt Counseling Bankruptcy Lawyers of Michigan Lawyers Detroit Bankruptcy Bankruptcy Lawyers of Michigan Walter Metzen Board Certified Consumer Bankruptcy Specialist 888-4WALTER Michigan Bankruptcy Centers Michigan Bankruptcy Counselors Michigan Bankruptcy Court Directory Fresh Start Michigan Bankruptcy Law Offices Michigan Bankruptcy Law Center Michigan Bankruptcy Laws Filing Bankruptcy in Michigan Michigan Bankruptcy Attorney Walter Metzen Specialist in Consumer Bankruptcy Laws Board Certified by the American Bankruptcy Institute Michigan Bankruptcy Online Michigan Bankruptcy Services. Michigan Chapter 13 Bankruptcy Attorneys Metro Detroit Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Lawyer Michigan Credit Counseling Credit Counselors of Michigan Michigan Debt Assistance Michigan Debt Relief Agency Fresh Start Bankruptcy Law Center Motor City Bankruptcy Laws Stop Wage Garnishment in Michigan Detroit Bankruptcy Lawyer Walter Metzen Consumer Bankruptcy Attorney Walter Metzen Michigan Fresh Start Lawyers Downriver Bankruptcy Lawyer Michigan Fresh Start Bankruptcy Offices of Detroit Bankruptcy Attorneys Detroit Filing Personal Bankruptcy in Michigan Filing Personal Bankruptcy in Michigan Fresh Start Bankruptcy Lawyers Fresh Start Bankruptcy Law Office of Detroit

 

 Content Footer